Hello, dear friend, you can consult us at any time if you have any questions, add WeChat: daixieit


FIN 422 Practice Midterm

Department of Finance and Statistical Analysis

2019


1. You are evaluating whether to build a petrochemical complex or a refinery plant in Strathcona county on behalf of investors.  Due to capacity constraints, you can only proceed with one of the two projects (i.e.  the projects are mutually exclusive).  The petrochemical complex requires $10 million i n upfront costs and i s expected to generate  $3 million per year (starting i n one year) i n perpetuity, and the refinery plant requires $5 million upfront and is expected to generate $2 million per year (starting in one year) in perpetuity. The cost of capital for both projects is k = 10%.

(a)  (2 points) What is the NPV for the petrochemical complex and for the refinery

plant? Which project (if any) should you choose based on the NPV rule?


Solution: The NPV for the petrochemical complex is NPVpetrol = -10+ = $20m. The NPV for the renery plant is NPVrefinery = -5 + = $15m. Therefore you should choose the petrochemical complex since it has the higher positive NPV.


(b)  (3 points) What is the IRR for the petrochemical complex and for the refinery plant? Which project (if any) should you choose based on the IRR rule?


Solution: The IRR is the discount rate that sets the NPV of the project to zero:

÷ 0 = -10 + - Rpetrol = 30%

÷ 0 = -5 + - Rrefinery = 40%

Since both IRRs are higher than the 10% cost of capital and Rrefinery is the higher of the two, the IRR rule indicates that you should select the renery project.

Solution: The incremental cash ows of switching from the renery plant to the petrochemical complex is -10 - (-5) = -$5m incremental outlay and 3 - 2 = $1m incremental inows in perpetuity. The IRR of this cash ow stream is R dened by 0 = -5 + which implies R = 20%.

The incremental cash flow is non-loan type (since it involves an initial cash outow followed by cash inows) and the IRR is higher than the 10% cost of capital, so the IRR indicates we should switch from the refinery to the petro- che