Hello, dear friend, you can consult us at any time if you have any questions, add WeChat: daixieit

A Titrimetric Study of the Effect of pH on Carboxyl Content of Oxidised Starch

1. Introduction

1.1 Background information

My mom likes to cook and sell her food, and she often uses food packaging such as plastic, but  this  led  to  a  huge  amount  of  waste  that  was  non-biodegradable.  After doing  some research,  I found that starch which was oxidised could be made into wrapping films as a biodegradable alternative, and I wondered how this typical foodstuff (starch) can be modified through chemical reactions.

The results of this experiment would contribute to the general understanding of the reaction condition, specifically pH, that is necessary to maximise the oxidation of starch as measured by the carboxyl content. While it may be intuitive to know that temperature can increase the rate of oxidation, using high temperatures may incur significant electricity and energy costs to be fully maintained. It is worth investigating other variables that can be used to maximise oxidation, like pH level which can be easily changed by the addition of certain alkaline or acidic substances.

During the investigation itself, some aspect of the methodology was modified to apply my learning.  The  common  method  of  starch   oxidation  is  to  use  sodium  hypochlorite  (in industries), but hydrogen peroxide may be a better reagent for this experiment because it decomposes into oxygen and water. Thus, it is more environmentally friendly. Discovering more about starch oxidation using hydrogen peroxide may benefit research into the possible transition from using sodium  hypochlorite to  hydrogen  peroxide as a  reagent  in  relevant industries.

1.2 Literature review

Apart from creation of biodegradable films, oxidised starch has many applications in other industries, such as paper printing and textile industries. Starch itself can be typically oxidised by  a  variety  of  oxidising  agents  such  as  sodium  hypochlorite  and  hydrogen  peroxide (Tolvanen et al., 2011).

Figure 1.2 - Oxidation of starch by hydrogen peroxide with an iron catalyst (Tolvanen et al., 2011)

The proposed mechanism is seen in Figure 1.2 above, though it should be noted that the reaction mechanism may change depending on the reaction conditions (Dias et al., 2011). At first, the hydroxyl groups undergo oxidation to form carbonyl groups then carboxyl groups (Sukhija et al., 2017). The extent of starch oxidation can therefore be measured by how many  carboxyl  groups  are  formed  at  the  end  of the  reaction.  This  is expressed as the number of carboxyl groups per 100 glucose units (COOH/100 GU) (Fonseca et al., 2015) or as a percentage.

Previous  research  has shown that  many factors affect the degree of starch oxidation. In particular, starch oxidised with sodium hypochlorite contained the highest amount of carboxyl groups (Yuniar et al., 2019), hence it would be interesting to see if it has the same effect with hydrogen   peroxide.   Other   factors   include   the   concentration  of  the  oxidising  agent, temperature and even the drying method used in the case of cassava starch (Dias et al., 2011).  For  this  experiment,  pH  will  be  varied  while  these  factors  (e.g.  temperature, concentration of oxidising agent) are controlled.

In this  investigation, starch  is  reacted as a slurry with hydrogen peroxide, to oxidise OH (hydroxyl)  groups  to  COOH  (carboxyl).  The  pH  of  this  slurry  and  eventual  mixture  with hydrogen  peroxide  is controlled  by adding  HCl and  NaOH. After the reaction, the starch slurry is washed, dried and filtered in order to remove the excess H+  ions (from HCl), Na+ (from NaOH) and other ions that may interfere with the titration. This ensures that the only NaOH which is present in the titration burette is the one reacting with the COOH groups.

1.3 Research question

To what extent does the  pH  level  (pH 4.00 - 9.00) of the reaction affect the percentage carboxyl content of starch oxidised by hydrogen peroxide?

1.4 Hypothesis

The carboxyl content of oxidised starch will be lowest at pH 7.00. As the pH increases or decreases away from pH 7.00, the carboxyl content of oxidised starch will increase.

This  hypothesis  is in line with studies by that found more acidic (Harmon et al., 1972) or more alkaline  pH  (specifically  pH 8.40 and  pH  10.0)  (Tolvanen  et  al., 2009) favours the formation of carboxyl groups compared to a neutral pH.

2. Methodology

2.1 Variables

Independent variable

pH of the reaction (pH 4.00, pH 5.00, pH 6.00, pH 7.00, pH 8.00, pH 9.00)

Dependent variable

Carboxyl content in starch, which will be measured through titration using NaOH (more detail in Procedure)

Table 2.1.1 - Independent and dependent variables

Controlled variables

Why it is controlled

How it is controlled

Temperature

Temperature affects the rate of reaction. Hence, the

amount of carboxyl after starch oxidation would

increase with temperature.

Temperature is kept

constant at 35.0°C through the use of a

thermostatically-monitored water bath during the

oxidation of starch.

This slightly elevated temperature was chosen in comparison to room temperature to increase the rate of reaction and

obtain high yield of oxidised starch. If the temperature was too high, some hydrogen peroxide will have naturally

decomposed to become oxygen and water, which means the concentration of oxidising agent would not be constant.

Reaction time

Reaction time was found to significantly increase the

carboxyl content of oxidised starch (Parovuori et al., 1995) because more hydroxyl

groups could be oxidised as time passes, which would introduce a different

independent variable.

The reaction time is kept constant at 10 minutes through the use of a

stopwatch to time the reaction.

Concentration of chemicals used

A change in hydrogen

peroxide concentration affects the amount of carboxyl groups present (Dias et al., 2011).

Other concentrations (NaOH and HCl) need to be kept

constant so as to not change the volume needed for the titration.

A standard solution of 1.50 mol dm-3 hydrogen peroxide was used throughout the

experiment. The

concentrations of NaOH and HCl are set at 0.1 mol dm-3 , and titration is carried out

with 0.005 mol dm-3 NaOH.

Dry mass of starch

The mass used for starch is an important component of

the final equation, so it should remain constant.

25.00 g of starch was

oxidised per trial. 10.00 g was used in the titration.

Table 2.1.2 - Controlled variables

2.2 Apparatus and materials

Apparatus:

1.   Conical flask (500 cm3)

2.   Measuring/graduated cylinder (100.0 ± 0.5 cm3)

Materials:

1. 100 g starch, (C6 H10O5)n

2.   100.0 cm3 of 1.50 mol dm-3 H2O2

3.   200.0 cm3 of 0.1 mol dm-3 NaOH


3.   Measuring/graduated cylinder (50.0 ± 0.5 cm3)

4.   Beaker (400 cm3)

5.   Burette (50.0 ± 0.05 cm3) and stand

6.   pH meter 0.01)

7.   Stopwatch (± 0.01 s)

8.   Thermometer (± 0.5 °C)

9.   Weighing balance (± 0.01 g)

10. Water bath

11. Filter papers

12. Filter funnel

13. Several droppers

14. Magnetic stirrer

15. Glass rod

4.   200.0 cm3 of 0.1 mol dm-3 HCl

5.   20.0 cm3 of 0.01 mol dm-3 AgNO3

6.   Distilled water

7.   Phenolphthalein

Table 2.2 - List of apparatus and materials along with quantities and uncertainties

2.3 Procedure

The following procedure is adapted from an experiment by Fonseca et al. (2015) with some modifications.

Oxidation of starch by hydrogen peroxide

1.   Measure 25.00 g (dry basis) of starch and place in 50.0 cm3  of distilled water in a 400 cm3  beaker and stir with a glass rod to form a starch slurry.

2.   Calibrate the pH meter with a standard solution of pH 4.00 and pH 7.00.

3.   Place the pH meter in the slurry.

4.  Adjust the pH of the starch slurry to pH to pH 4.00 using 0.1 mol dm-3 HCl and 0.1 mol dm-3 NaOH where necessary.

5.   Heat the starch slurry at 35.0°C  using a water bath and add 30.0 cm3  of 1.50 mol dm-3 H2O2 .

6.  After adding H2O2 , maintain the pH at pH 4.00 using the same method described in step 3.

7.   Let the mixture react for 10 minutes, timed with a stopwatch.

8.  After the reaction, filter the slurry through a filter paper in a filter funnel into a conical flask.

9.  Wash the starch slurry with distilled water and refilter through filter paper in a filter funnel.

10. Dry the starch in an oven at 60.0°C for 10 minutes.

11. Repeat steps 1-7 using different pH values: pH 5.00, pH 6.00, pH 7.00, pH 8.00, pH 9.00.

Titration with NaOH

12. Weigh 10.00 g of the dry, oxidised starch.

13. Mix the starch sample in 25.0 cm3  of 0.1 mol dm-3   HCl. Stir using a magnetic stirrer for 30 minutes.

14. Filter the slurry (the residue) and wash with distilled water until there are no chloride ions.

a.   To  test  this,  add  two  drops  of  0.01  mol  dm-3   AgNO3   solution.  If  a  white precipitate (AgCl) forms, there are still chloride ions.   testing the filtrate

15. Place this slurry in 100.0 cm3  of distilled water.    in conical flask

16. Heat this starch slurry in a boiling water bath for 15 minutes to gelatinise.

17. Add 0.005 mol dm-3 NaOH into a burette.

18. Add 3 drops of phenolphthalein as an indicator.   in the flask

19. Immediately titrate the heated sample with 0.005 mol dm-3 NaOH.

20. Measure the volume of NaOH needed to make the solution reach pH 8.30 in step 17.   neutralized

Figure 2.3 - Computer drawn figure of the experimental setup

2.4 Evaluation of procedure

Several    important    modifications    were    considered.    Originally   the   titration    utilised phenolphthalein as an indicator for the first few trials. This was preferred because the colour change of the indicator would be sharp and quick, allowing the titration to stop immediately close to the equivalence point, in comparison to a pH meter that has a lag time. However, the opaque nature of the starch slurry made the colour change hard to see at times. Hence the titration is done until a pH of 8.30 is reached, and this is in line with other methodologies by   Matsuguma   et   al.   (2009).   Notably   the   range   pH   8.30   to   10.00   is   also   when phenolphthalein would sharply turn pink. To prevent overshoot, NaOH should be added in small increments (not continuously) and the reading on the pH meter should stabilise before adding more NaOH.

Additionally, after several preliminary trials, it was found that using 0.010 mol dm-3 NaOH for the titration led to very small titre volumes. Thus the solution was diluted in order to obtain titre  values  within  the  20.0  cm3   to  increase  precision  of  the  readings  (more  significant figures).

2.5 Risk assessment

Safety considerations: H2O2  is a strong oxidiser. Also, skin exposure may result in severe skin burns (Lab Chem, 2017). Though NaOH, HCl and AgNO3  are non-toxic at smaller concentrations, they can still be irritants or caustic in nature. Thus rubber gloves are utilised in handling all chemicals throughout the experiments. A lab coat is also worn along with safety goggles.

Ethical considerations: There were no ethical considerations to take into account.

Environmental considerations: Avoid  release of chemicals into the environment. Chemicals should  not  be  poured down the sink.  Instead  all  hazardous chemicals should be collected in a specific container for hazardous substances, to be disposed of professionally by the school lab.

3. Data collection

3.1 Qualitative observations

Before  heating, starch  is  insoluble  in water.  Most of the starch  would  settle  to  the  bottom  of  the  beaker  if  not periodically mixed. The resulting suspension is an opaque white  colour.  In  terms  of  colour,  oxidised  starch  was indistinguishable from unmodified starch.

Figure  3.1 shows  the  suspension,  with  all the  oxidised starch, after initial titration with NaOH until pH 8.30. A faint pink colour is produced in the titration, due to the presence of  the  phenolphthalein  indicator,  thus  showing  that  the acidic carboxyl groups  have  been  neutralised.  However, this pink colour is faint due to the colour of the starch not being fully colourless. Additionally, it was observed that the pink colour would form, then after stirring, disappear if the colour was not strong enough.

3.2 Raw data


Table 3.2 - Initial and final burette readings of the 0.005 mol dm-3 NaOH titre against oxidised starch.