STAT6200 Assessment 2 Paper Excerpts (T2_2023)
Hello, dear friend, you can consult us at any time if you have any questions, add WeChat: daixieit
STAT6200 Assessment 2 Paper Excerpts (T2_2023)
PART 1
Q1. A longitudinal cohort study assessed the course of low back pain (LBP) among nurses employed by a large university hospital in Switzerland. The cohort was followed up primarily at 1 year (cohort 91-92) and the final follow up at 8 years (cohort 92-99). As part of the investigation, the study has reported the following table where the association between the lifetime duration of LBP, and the duration of LBP within the preceding 12 months is presented.
Using the given information in the table:
a. Comment on the association between the lifetime duration of LBP, and the duration of LBP within the preceding 12 months for cohort 91-92 and cohort 92- 99. Base your interpretation on the p-values using a significance level of 0.05. (2 points)
b. Why was ANOVA used to assess the association between the lifetime duration of LBP, and the duration of LBP within the preceding 12 months? (2 points)
c. How would you report / interpret the data inside the red box in the above table? (1 point)
Q2. A large population-based cohort study investigated a group of 1698 women to determine the association between dietary macronutrient intake in the preconception period, with birth weight. In the study, the mother’s body mass index (BMI) was classified into Quintiles and birth weight was converted into a z-score. To assess the relationship between the mean birth weight and maternal BMI, the following plot was reported in the study.
Using the given information in the graph:
a. Identify the maternal BMI quantile for which the birth weight (z-score) is not statically significant. Estimate the corresponding mean birth weight with the approximate confidence interval (CI). (2 points)
b. What is the maximum mean birth weight. Is that weight statistically significant? Explain based on the CI. (1.5 points)
c. Approximate the difference in mean birth weight between Q5 and Q1 BMI quintile. (1.5 points)
Q3. A study on participants from the Prediction and Prevention of Preeclampsia and Intrauterine Growth Restriction (PREDO) cohort investigated the link between maternal early pregnancy obesity and depressive symptoms during and after pregnancy. The following table represents the association between early pregnancy BMI and depressive symptoms and provided the statistics in terms of mean difference, confidence interval and p-value.
Using the given information in the table:
a. Is the mean difference an absolute or relative measure of the effect size? (1.5 points)
b. What statistical test is appropriate to define the association between BMI categories and depression (assume outcome variable is not normally distributed)? Justify your answer. (1.5 points)
c. Is the mean difference for obese women statistically significant during pregnancy and after pregnancy? Explain based on the CI. (2 points)
Q4. A cross-sectional study assessed the prevalence and association of obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) prevalence in South Asians and White Europeans with type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM).
As part of investigation, the following table provides the prevalence of OSA among South Asian and White European with T2D
Using the given information in the table:
a. What is the prevalence (%, n) of having moderate to severe OSA among South Asian participants? (1.5 points)
b. What is the difference in prevalence of OSA (%, n) between White Europeans and South Asians with T2DM (show the calculation). Is the severity of OSA between White Europeans and South Asians participants statistically significant? (2 points)
c. What is the Inter-Quartile Range (IQR) of Apnea-hypopnea index for South Asian and White European participants? (1.5 points)
Q5. The table below contains odds ratios and their 95% confidence intervals for a number of outcomes for women in the treatment group (cervical pessary) and in the expectant management group (ignore the p value column). The data is source from a randomised controlled trial on the use of a cervical pessary in women with a short cervix to prevent pre-term births.
Using the given information in the table:
a. Do you think the information above supports the use of a cervical pessary to reduce pre-term births (any birth prior to 37 weeks)? What is the basis of your answer? (3 points)
b. Based on the information above, would you recommend the use of cervical pessary to reduce chorioamnionitis and pregnancy bleeding? Justify your answer. (2 points)
PART 2
Q1. Table 2 below is taken from a study that examined changes in traumatic stress and co-occurring emotional and behavioural symptoms following treatment in a sample of children treated for complex trauma at a usual care clinical agency. The table shows the cut-off for statistical significance was set at p< .008.
Source: Data from Dauber et al., (2015)
a. From Table 2, what inferential test statistic is applicable to test the hypothesis that children would show significant declines in symptoms from pre- to post- treatment? Why was this test appropriate for the analysis? What is the null and alternative hypothesis? (3 points)
b. Briefly explain the change in pre- and post-treatment trauma symptoms for the analytic sample in reference to the alpha value of <.008. (6 points)
c. How can you justify the difference between pre-and post-treatment trauma symptoms based on Cohen’s d (the measure of effect size)? According to Cohen (1988), effect size estimates can be interpreted as small (d = 0.0–0.20), medium (d = 0.30–0.50), and large (d = 0.60–0.80). (6 points)
Q2. Table 3 below is taken from a study that examined associations between clinical, functioning, and sociodemographic factors and frequency of tobacco use in the adolescent and young adult groups.
Source: Data from Cotton et al., (2022)
a. From Table 3, define the significant variables that are associated with regular tobacco use in the adolescent group (12-17 years). Report both the p-value and confidence interval (CI) from the univariate analysis. The reference alpha value is ≤ 0.05. (5 points)
b. From Table 3, define the null and alternative hypotheses considering the variable between current relationship status and regular tobacco use. Explain the association between current relationship status and regular tobacco use among young adults (age 18-2 years) based on 95% CI from multivariable analysis. (5 points)
PART 3
Q1. The figure below is from a longitudinal ecological study to investigate whether the uneven rise in prosperity between 1999 and 2008 accounted for differential increases in life expectancy (the outcome variable) in English local authorities (LA). The authors measured trends in prosperity as being represented by corresponding changes in unemployment, in household income, and in educational achievement, these were the covariates. A deprivation variable was also added to the model.
Source: Data from Barr et al. (2012)
a. Do you think the model has a better fit (greater explanatory power) for men or for women? (3 points)
b. Whose life expectancy changes the most when unemployment decreases – men or women? Does it increase or decrease? How can you tell? (4 points)
Q2. The figure below from a study to assess the risk of adverse perinatal events of vaccination of pregnant women with an MF59 adjuvanted vaccine (a flu vaccine).
Source: Data from Rubinstein et al (2013)
a. What does the figure above tell you about the odds (adjusted) for vaccinated women, compared to non-vaccinated women, of delivering pre-term or having babies with low birthweight? (3 points)
Q3. The table is from a study was to determine the accuracy of parentally reported weights and lengths (of infants) at 12 months of age compared with measured weights and lengths obtained from a paediatrician’s visit, and to examine factors associated with parentally reported inaccuracies.
Source: Data from Hazrati et al. (2015)
a. Interpret the Pearson’s correlation coefficients given in the table. (4 points)
b. Explain the circumstances which would persuade you to use Spearman’s correlation coefficient rather than Pearson’s. (2 points)
Q4. The figure below is from a time trend analysis comparing the actual number of suicides in 2009 with the number that would be expected based on trends before the financial crisis (2000–2007). The objective was to investigate the impact of the 2008 global economic crisis on international trends in suicide and to identify sex/age groups and countries most affected. The table shows Spearman’s correlation coefficients, 95% confidence intervals and p-values, between changes in unemployment rate and suicide rate between 2007 and 2009 in 50 countries, stratified by unemployment rate before the financial crisis in 2007.
Source: Data from Chang et al. (2013)
a. What do these results suggest about the association between changes in unemployment and suicide rates? (3 points)
Q5. The table below is from a study to investigate the temporal trends in socioeconomic inequalities in adult obesity in Scottish population between 1995 and 2010/2011 using multiple socioeconomic indicators. The authors hypothesised that socioeconomic inequalities in adult obesity have widened throughout the study period in Scotland. The table contains the results of a chi-squared test of temporal trends in obesity prevalence within each socioeconomic stratum. Also shown is a chi-squared test for equality of proportions of body mass index (BMI) across years.
Data source: Jin et al. (2015)
a. Interpret the results presented in the table. (4 points)
b. Why was the chi-square the appropriate test to use in this analysis? (2 points)
PART 4
Read the Pasdar et al. (2021) paper and answer the following questions:
Here is the link to the paper:
https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-022-13166- 0#Sec11
Q1. In Table 3, check how the data for socioeconomic status (SES), body mass index (BMI) and gender were reported. Classify whether they are nominal, ordinal, interval or ratio. Justify your answers. (3 points)
Q2. Table 3 presents the baseline characteristics in cases and sub-cohort groups. Which inferential tests were used to compare the following variables between the groups: a) gender, b) SES, c) BMI, and d) total vegetables intake? Justify your answers. (5 points)
Q3. In table 5, why do you think the Pearson correlation was used instead of Spearman’s correlation? Explain the correlation between healthy eating index and dietary pattern based on the given r and p values obtained from the Pearson correlation. You must provide your justification along with relevant data. Please do not simply copy and paste the answer from the paper. (5 points)
Q4. In Table 7 (Model 1), identify for which Healthy Eating Index (HEI)-2015 components did the participants show a lower risk of hypertension (HTN) incidence. Justify your answers by providing the values and explaining them. (6 points)
Q5. Briefly describe why the Cox proportional hazards regression model was used in this study. In Table 6, the participants with the highest tertile of the plant-based dietary pattern were at lower risk of incident HTN in both crude and adjusted model (Model IV) (HR: 0.69; 95% CI: 0.54–0.9) and (HR: 0.70; 95% CI: 0.53–0.94). Given the results of the regression analysis, which hypothesis should be accepted based on the confidence intervals? Explain why. (6 points)
2023-07-27